RPA vs. Workflow Automation: What's the Difference?

RPA, workflow automation, process automation, iPaaS – the terms are often used interchangeably. But they mean different things. In this article, we clarify the differences and show when you should use which approach.

The Short Version

What is RPA (Robotic Process Automation)?

RPA software mimics human interactions with the computer:

• Clicks buttons
• Fills out forms
• Copies data between windows
• Reads screen content
• Navigates through menus

Imagine: An invisible employee sitting at the computer doing exactly what you show them – over and over again.

How RPA Works

1. You show the bot: "Open SAP"
You show the bot: "Click on field X"
You show the bot: "Type in this data"
You show the bot: "Click Save"
The bot repeats this 1000x

RPA Advantages

No System Changes Required

The bot works with the interface. The underlying system isn't touched.

Legacy Systems Can Be Automated

Old software without an API? No problem. The bot clicks like a human.

Fast Implementation for Simple Cases

If a process works manually, the bot can take it over.

RPA Disadvantages

Fragile

UI changes? Bot breaks. Button moved? Bot can't find it.

Slow

The bot has to wait for pages to load. Like a human.

Expensive

Enterprise RPA licenses cost $10,000-50,000 per bot per year.

Maintenance-Intensive

Every UI change requires a bot update.

Hard to Scale

More volume = more bots = more licenses = more cost.

When RPA Makes Sense

• Legacy systems without API (AS/400, old SAP versions)
• No IT resources available for integration
• Short-term solution until system replacement
• Desktop applications without interfaces
• Regulated environments where systems cannot be modified

What is Workflow Automation?

Workflow automation connects applications via their APIs (Application Programming Interfaces):

• Data flows directly from system to system
• No user interface involved
• Event-driven (Trigger → Action)
• Runs in the background

Imagine: A data highway where information is automatically transported between apps.

How Workflow Automation Works

1. Trigger: New order in Shopify
Action: Create contact in HubSpot
Action: Send Slack message to team
Action: Create invoice in accounting software
Action: Add task in Asana

Everything happens in seconds, without anyone seeing or clicking anything.

Workflow Automation Advantages

Fast and Reliable

API communication in milliseconds. No UI dependency.

Scalable

1 execution or 100,000 – hardly any difference.

Affordable

Modern tools cost $10-500/month.

Low Maintenance

APIs are more stable than UIs.

Real-Time Possible

Immediate reaction to events.

Workflow Automation Disadvantages

API Required

No interface, no integration. Legacy systems often left out.

Technical Understanding Helpful

Not as intuitive as "showing the bot what to do."

Dependent on API Limits

Some APIs have rate limits.

When Workflow Automation Makes Sense

• Modern cloud apps (Salesforce, HubSpot, Slack, etc.)
• Data flows between systems
• Real-time requirements
• High volumes
• Long-term, scalable solutions

Direct Comparison

Example: Data from Excel to CRM

RPA Approach:

1. Bot opens Excel
Bot reads row 1
Bot opens CRM in browser
Bot clicks "New Contact"
Bot types data into fields
Bot clicks "Save"
Back to step 2 for next row
→ Duration: 2 minutes per record

Workflow Automation Approach:

1. Excel file is uploaded
All rows are processed in parallel
CRM API creates all contacts
→ Duration: 5 seconds for 100 records

Example: Invoice Processing

RPA Approach:

1. Bot opens email program
Bot finds invoice in attachment
Bot opens PDF
Bot reads with OCR
Bot opens accounting system
Bot types in data
Bot saves

Workflow Automation Approach:

1. Email arrives (webhook/trigger)
Attachment is extracted
OCR API reads PDF
Accounting API receives data

Cost Comparison

Reliability

When to Use Which?

Decision Tree

Does the system have an API?
├── Yes → Workflow Automation
└── No
    ├── Will the system be replaced soon?
    │   ├── Yes → RPA as transitional solution
    │   └── No → RPA or custom integration
    └── Can an API be built?
        ├── Yes, economically → Build API + Workflow
        └── No → RPA

Specific Recommendations

Use Workflow Automation for:

• Cloud-to-cloud integrations
• E-commerce automation
• Marketing automation
• CRM processes
• Document workflows with modern tools

Use RPA for:

• SAP GUI (older versions)
• AS/400 / Mainframe
• Desktop applications without API
• Citrix/Remote Desktop environments
• Regulated legacy systems

Combine Both When:

• Hybrid landscape (modern + legacy)
• Legacy data needs to go into cloud systems
• Gradual modernization is planned

Hybrid Approaches

In reality, pure forms are rare. Often a combination makes sense:

Example: Order-to-Cash Process

[Shopify] ──API──> [Make.com] ──API──> [HubSpot]
                       │
                       ▼
                   [RPA Bot]
                       │
                       ▼
                   [SAP GUI]

Modern systems via API, legacy via RPA.

Tools That Can Do Both

• Power Automate: Workflow + Desktop Automation
• n8n: Workflow + Custom Code for anything
• UiPath: RPA + increasingly API integration

The Future: Hyperautomation

The trend is toward "hyperautomation":

• RPA + Workflow Automation + AI
• One orchestration layer controls everything
• Intelligent decisions
• Self-healing automations

But as of today (2026): Start with Workflow Automation, add RPA where necessary.

Checklist: Making the Right Choice

Workflow Automation is probably better if: RPA is probably better if:

Conclusion

RPA is a powerful tool – for the right use cases. But it's often overused where simpler solutions would work better. Workflow Automation should be your default. It's faster, cheaper, and more reliable for the majority of use cases.

The question is not "RPA or Workflow Automation?" but "Where do I use which?"

---

Not sure which approach is right for your systems? We analyze your IT landscape and recommend the optimal solution – or combination.